PayPal resolution center decided in my favor and I received a full refund. Took 3 weeks. I urge anyone taken by this scam to immediately file a claim with PayPal. Include screen-caps like I did.
Also: as soon as my resolution was decided, i received several suspicious emails saying my PayPal account had been locked out and I needed to send my info to some anonymous link. Hmm... nice try.
I've attached pics of the fake site and also my resolution from PayPal.
Thanks to everyone who posted about this!